Bennett’s Fracture: Expert Insights

Bennett’s fracture can be defined as a crack or break in the first carpometacarpal joint at the base of the thumb. This injury specifically involves a break at the base of the thumb bone (first metacarpal) where it meets the wrist. The term ‘Bennett’ originates from Edward Hallaran Bennett, who first described this fracture in the late 19th century, giving it its eponymous name and historical significance. A Bennett fracture is a common intra-articular fracture at the base of the thumb bone, typically seen as a fracture-dislocation with a characteristic triangular fragment on radiographs. The cartilage that covers it helps in the extensive movement of the thumb and maintains joint stability. In most cases, Bennett’s fracture causes this ligament to get detached from the bones, leading to a dislocation of the carpometacarpal joint. The fracture fragment is often displaced radially due to the pull of the abductor pollicis longus muscle. For anatomical comparison and surgical considerations, the relationship to the second metacarpal is important. If not treated properly, the injury may result in loss of functionality, thumb weakness and the development of Osteoarthritis at the base of the thumb.

Causes

Thumb injury due to punching something hard
Falling on the hand with the thumb partially flexed
Work-related injuries
Motor vehicle accidents
Contact sports injuries, such as in boxing, rugby and soccer

Symptoms

Pain Swelling and tenderness at the base of the thumb
Difficulty grasping objects
Visible deformity in the thumb and wrist
Joint instability
Bruising

Diagnosis

To diagnose a Bennett’s fracture, the orthopedic doctor may physically examine the site of injury to look for visible deformity and signs of dislocation. He may conduct certain imaging tests, such as X-ray, CT scan or MRI, to confirm the exact location of injury and extent of dislocation of the carpometacarpal joint. Radiographic views of the palm (palmar aspect) are important for accurate assessment of the fracture and to evaluate the displacement of the thumb bone.

Treatment

Conservative treatment is not usually recommended as the fracture involves displaced joint surfaces that need to be aligned back to their normal position. However, in case of a hairline fracture without any significant displacement, the orthopedic doctor may perform a closed reduction procedure. In this, the thumb may be manually manipulated using axial traction with abduction and pronation to restore the original position of the bone.
The patient may be advised to wear a splint or cast to immobilize the thumb and promote a faster healing. Casting and splinting are traditional immobilization techniques used to stabilize the fracture, but they may have limitations in maintaining reduction, especially in displaced Bennett fractures. Immobilization is typically maintained for 3-4 weeks or up to 4-6 weeks depending on the severity and stability of the fracture.
Surgical intervention may be required for a major Bennett’s fracture. It may also be required to treat a shortened or abnormally rotated thumb as a result of the injury. Metal screws, wires and plates may be inserted to hold the broken bone fragments in place. K-wires are commonly used for percutaneous fixation and stabilization, especially in minimally displaced fractures, as an alternative to screws for temporary stabilization.
A comparison of outcomes between open reduction and internal fixation versus closed reduction and percutaneous fixation is important in determining the most effective treatment for Bennett fracture.
Physical therapy may be recommended post-surgery to reinstate complete functionality of the thumb.

Understanding Bennett’s Fracture

Bennett’s fracture is a specific type of injury that affects the base of the thumb, where the first metacarpal bone meets the wrist bones, particularly the trapezium. This intra-articular fracture involves the joint surface and is most often the result of a direct blow to a partially flexed metacarpal, which can occur during contact sports or martial arts. The stability of this joint is largely maintained by the anterior oblique ligament, and when this ligament is disrupted, it can lead to significant fracture displacement and joint instability. Understanding the mechanics and implications of a Bennett’s fracture is crucial for orthopedic surgeons and healthcare providers to ensure effective treatment and optimal recovery for patients.

Causes and Risk Factors

Bennett’s fracture most commonly occurs when there is forced abduction of the first metacarpal, such as when the thumb is pushed away from the hand with significant force. This can happen due to a direct blow to the thumb, a fall onto an outstretched hand, or during activities that involve axial loading, like catching oneself during a fall or striking an object in contact sports, boxing or martial arts. Individuals who participate in these high-risk activities or have a history of previous thumb injuries or inherent weakness in the thumb, are more susceptible to this type of fracture. The unique anatomy of the first metacarpal base makes it particularly vulnerable to these forces, increasing the risk of injury during both everyday activities and athletic pursuits.

Anatomy and Pathophysiology

The thumb’s unique range of motion and strength are made possible by the complex anatomy of the first metacarpal bone and its articulation with the trapezium, one of the wrist bones. The anterior oblique ligament, which attaches from the palmar ulnar aspect of the first metacarpal to the trapezium, is a key stabilizer of this joint. When a direct blow is delivered to a partially flexed metacarpal, the force can cause a fracture at the base of the thumb, often resulting in displacement of the bone fragment. The abductor pollicis longus muscle, which inserts along the first metacarpal shaft, can further pull the fractured segment away from its normal position, leading to fracture dislocation and instability of the joint. This combination of ligament disruption and muscular pull makes Bennett’s fracture particularly challenging to treat and prone to complications if not properly managed.

Symptoms and Diagnosis

Patients with a Bennett’s fracture typically experience acute pain, swelling, and bruising at the base of the thumb, along with noticeable weakness and limited movement in the thumb. During a physical exam, an orthopedic surgeon will assess the metacarpal bone and joint for tenderness, deformity, and instability. A detailed medical history helps identify the mechanism of injury and any previous thumb problems. Imaging studies, such as X-rays or CT scans, are essential to confirm the diagnosis, evaluate the extent of the fracture, and assess for displacement or involvement of the articular surface. Comparing the injured thumb to the uninjured side can also provide valuable information about the degree of swelling, deformity, and functional loss.

Treatment Options

The management of Bennett’s fracture is tailored to the severity and displacement of the injury. For fractures with minimal displacement, closed reduction followed by percutaneous pinning may be sufficient to realign and stabilize the bone. In more complex cases, open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) is often required, using screws, pins, or plates to secure the fracture fragments and maintain reduction. Immobilization with a thumb spica cast or splint is commonly used to protect the thumb and wrist during the healing process. Rest, ice, and elevation are recommended to reduce swelling in the initial phase. Physical therapy is an important part of rehabilitation, helping to restore strength and mobility to the thumb. The primary goals of treatment are to achieve anatomical reduction, maintain reduction, and prevent long-term complications such as joint instability or post-traumatic arthritis.

Your path to recovery starts here. Schedule an appointment with our specialized orthopedic surgeons today. Book your appointment online or call (972) 492-1334